Over the long-term, you want to grow the number of your above-average customers so they make up a larger part of your customer base.
You should absolutely continue to grow your customer base as a whole through customer acquisition. You just want to accumulate more above-average customers as you go.
There is no best number of above-average customers. What is best for one store might not apply to another.
Ideally you want it high and to be growing over-time. A good segmenting system like Repeat Customer Insights should keep track of it month by month for you.
Eric Davis
Learn which products build the best customers
Find which products create the most valuable customers with the First Product Analysis in Repeat Customer Insights. It goes beyond your best sellers by looking at long-term purchasing and retention behavior of your customers.