How to discover why your Shopify store's average order value keeps shrinking

When your Shopify store has a large drop-off in its Average Order Value, that means your loyal customers are spending less and less with each purchase. That sucks because the major benefit of having loyal customers is that they spend more and more with each visit, and pay back any acquisition costs.

Before you can fix the problem though, you need to first find out where it's happening. Average Order Value is such a flaky metric that you could negatively affect it with the wrong corrective corrective actions.

Finding your Average Order Value drop-offs with your repeat customers

Unfortunately Shopify's reports don't yet have a clear way to calculate your Average Order Value segmented by the customer step.

In order for you to you understand the concept of drop-offs, I'll be showing you the reports from Repeat Customer Insights. Here's a version of the report we're going to use:


1. Compare the Average Order Value for each step

Since Repeat Customer Insights already calculates the AOV for each step, we will need to compare them.

Looking at the steps for the first three orders you can see they vary a bit:

2. Skip the first order step

Because drop-offs are a comparison between steps, we're going to skip the first order step.

Comparing how much a customer spent on their first order versus their 0th or non-existent order doesn't make sense.

3. Divide the values by the previous amount

Starting with the second order step, we want to divide the prior order step (first, $113.72) by the current order step (second, $153.90)

-------- = 1.35

This value is a percentage so 1.35 is 135%. That means there is a 35% improvement in the average order value from the first order to the second order.

4. Continue on for each step

You'll want to continue on this process for each step until you go through every order step.

I'll do one more to illustrate the second to the third order:

-------- = 0.938

For this step, because the value is below 1 the Average Order Value dropped by 6.2%. Not a significant drop-off but it's something to watch for.

I like to look drop-offs of 20% or more for optimization.

Discovering the drop-offs automatically

Depending on how many customers you have, this calculation could take you anywhere from an hour to a few days. It's easy to do, but time-consuming.

I showed you how Repeat Customer Insights will help calculate the Average Order Value for each order step.

What I didn't show you was that Repeat Customer Insights now calculates Average Order Value drop-off for you automatically. Any step with a 20% or greater drop-off will be flagged and you'll get recommendations on how to improve it. You can learn more about this automatic Average Order Value drop-off detection in this article.

Analyze your customer's behaviors before they defect

Your customers aren't yours forever. Some might have defected today, never to be seen again.
You need to analyze your customer behavior so you can reach them before they defect.

Learn more

Topics: Average order value Repeat customers

Would you like a daily tip about Shopify?

Each tip includes a way to improve your store: customer analysis, analytics, customer acquisition, CRO... plus plenty of puns and amazing alliterations.